Interview with the Head of the HR Department of the RPI "UzEngineering"

"What should we build a house, or Cadres decide everything"

Interview with the head of the HR Department of the Republican Design Institute "Uzengineering" under the Cabinet of Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan Matnazarova Galina Sobirovna, who has more than 20 years of experience in the personnel field of the construction industry.

Galina Sobirovna, there are many questions, and they are all relevant. The construction industry has been developing quite rapidly in recent years. Does its staffing keep up with this forward movement?

Good afternoon. Staffing is actually quite a sore point, and not only for the construction industry, but also for the engineering sector as a whole. It's no secret that the existing educational system today does not meet the full needs of the construction complex in high-quality human resources. Currently, work is underway in this area, but this is still not enough for such a large-scale industry, moreover, it is also growing so dynamically.

I will give some figures. According to the State Statistics Committee, at the beginning of November this year there were more than 46 thousand construction enterprises in the republic, more than 4 thousand were created in Uzbekistan in just 10 months of this year, and almost 14 thousand in the last three years. More than 9,5 thousand construction organizations work in Tashkent alone today. If we take into account that a foreman, an engineer, a construction accountant and, of course, the builders themselves should work at a minimum in a construction organization, then the situation with staffing becomes obvious…

The shortage of skilled workers at construction sites, unfortunately, is filled for the most part by low-skilled, inexperienced, and sometimes poorly educated workers, which affects both the quality and safety of construction.

At the same time, everything is not simple with the current system of construction education, one of the main drawbacks of which is its isolation from practice. Although the theoretical training of graduates is quite good, they own software products, nevertheless they do not have practical work skills. And in construction universities and colleges, production practices are often conducted formally, there is no need to talk about internships at real facilities...

The construction organizations themselves are not particularly interested in taking students to practice, as this entails responsibility on their part for the safety of students, as well as separation from the main work of the practice managers.

As a result, university and college students often practice at the educational institution itself. Graduates who come to production spend three or four years just to master the initial practical basics of the profession, while their peers in developed countries are much more experienced, and they leave universities practically professionals in their field.

And what measures is the state taking? How is it trying to make up for the shortage of personnel?

In the vast majority of cases, universities, as well as vocational colleges and technical schools close part of the need for personnel. For example, for the 2022-2023 academic year, the quota for admission to the bachelor's degree in the Tashkent Institute of Architecture and Civil Engineering was 1,100 students, this is 21 areas of study, in the Samarkand State Institute of Architecture and Civil Engineering - a little more than 1,700 students in 18 areas. Builders and specialists with secondary special education are trained by technical schools and colleges (there are about 15 of them in the structure of the Ministry of Construction throughout the republic).

Noticeable shifts in terms of staffing of the project sphere followed with the adoption in February 2018 of Presidential Decree No. PP-3557 "On measures to further improve design work and the system of training design engineers in basic sectors of the economy." So, since 2018, the Republican Design Institute "Uzengineering" has started work on improving the system of training engineers in the field of design and project management, with the involvement of specialists and design engineers from foreign educational institutions and engineering companies. Ultimately, it is planned to increase professionalism and develop practical skills among students, as well as familiarize them with modern requirements in industrial construction, design, project management, industrial development and other fields of activity.

Also, in June 2021, by the decision of the Head of the country, the university "New Uzbekistan" was established in Tashkent. The main task of the university is the training of promising personnel with skills and competencies based on educational programs of foreign universities. The educational process at the university is organized in cooperation with reputable universities of foreign countries, and admission examinations are conducted by the University of Cambridge, curricula are developed jointly with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the Technical University of Munich. These universities will also help in quality control of education. The University has five faculties, including engineering. The head of the country has set the task for the first year to assign university students to the branches of economics and research centers. There is still a lot to do, but the first serious steps have already been taken.

I wonder how builders and designers improve their skills today?

According to the standard established scheme, design engineers and builders improve their qualifications in the Advanced Training Centers at the Tashkent and Samarkand Architectural and Construction Institutes. Specialists of working professions – on the basis of professional colleges of the structure of the Ministry of Construction, there are 15 of them in the republic. In addition, professional development is carried out by specialized organizations that have the appropriate license.

Also, since 2019, professional development of engineering workers has been carried out by the Association of Consulting Engineers of Uzbekistan and the Republican Design Institute "Uzengineering" within the framework of specialized training courses, trainings, seminars. Foreign experts from Korea, Germany, Russia, Latvia with sufficient practical experience are invited as speakers and lecturers. For 2017-2022 . experts from such companies as Hyundai Engineering and Construction, SK Engineering and Construction, the SES Foundation, FULBRIGHT, the Central Institute of Model Design and Urban Planning, the Unified Center for Additional Education in Moscow, the St. Petersburg Power Engineering Institute for Advanced Training and many others conducted more than 65 courses and trainings on various topics of engineering design, project management, the study of FIDIC contract system, BIM design technologies. As a result, through the joint efforts of the Association and the Republican Design Institute over the past three years, more than 1.5 thousand managers and specialists have improved their qualifications.

We have touched upon the issue of personnel qualifications. Someone trains a specialist in a profession, assigns qualifications, improves it, but surely someone has to check this qualification?

In world practice, for example, in countries such as the USA, Great Britain, Japan, there is, and quite successfully, a two-stage mechanism for assigning and confirming qualifications as a guarantee of the quality of engineering personnel training. The first stage is the public professional accreditation of engineering educational programs implemented in universities. The second stage is the certification and registration of professional engineers by independent, usually non–governmental organizations using appropriate criteria and procedures. Let me explain: a person who has graduated from an accredited program must work from four to seven years in the specialty, do project work, continuously improve their qualifications, and then pass certification exams. If all these issues are successfully resolved, he can be enrolled in the register of professional engineers. The presence of such two stages forces universities to provide high-quality training of graduates, and then stimulates the further development of already practicing engineers.

We are also going to this… In accordance with the Presidential Decree issued in November 2018

UP-5577 provides to establish the procedure according to which the Association of Consulting Engineers of Uzbekistan is entrusted with the certification of specialists in the field of design and construction. Currently, organizational issues are being resolved to approve the certification procedure, as well as the mechanism and procedures. Since this cannot be done at one time, with the co-financing of the European Union and the practical support of the Latvian company CLEANTECH LATVIA, the Association is directly involved in the implementation of the ENGINE project, which is aimed, among other things, at supporting the implementation of the mechanism for certification of engineers and requirements for the quality of engineering work in the republic. The Ministry of Construction of the Republic has a working group on the implementation of the certification mechanism, meetings are held at different levels, discussions.

In fact, the state, pushing design or construction organizations to unite into communities, transfers part of its functions to control and regulate the construction market to market participants themselves. In other words, based on practice, each professional association sets its own standards and rules of professional activity, mandatory for all members, and monitors their implementation.

To summarize. Certification of engineers is needed like air today. An exam is required to confirm the competence of specialists, their knowledge, experience and ability to solve the tasks assigned to the industry. A filter is needed that would reduce the number of "random people" in design and construction activities who are not able to make decisions correctly, perform assigned tasks and thereby pose a threat to cause damage to society and the state.

Galina Sobirovna, and what advantages does membership in the Association give to construction and design organizations?

Let's start with the fact that members of the Association can be legal entities and individuals, including foreign ones, who carry out professional activities in the project field. At the same time, legal entities and individuals, including foreign ones, engaged in professional activities in construction and other areas related to design and construction activities, may be associate members.

As for the advantages, among them are the right to participate in events held by the Association (seminars, conferences, master classes, trainings), the opportunity to receive advice and recommendations from leading foreign consultants, the advantage in enrolling in courses and trainings conducted by the Association, the possibility of using the Association's logo together with the logo of the International Federation of Consulting Engineers FIDIK.

In the future, after the formation of the Association as a professional community is completed, it is an opportunity to implement its own initiatives and proposals through the Association, the possibility of collective appeals on behalf of the Association members to various state bodies, access to information about in–demand specialists and the main trends in the development of the engineering market both in the republic and abroad, as well as to various registries and contact information (members of the Association, certified specialists, university graduates (novice specialists) in the areas and others. An important factor will be the assistance of the Association in promoting the interests of its members in participating in international tenders on the territory of the Republic of Uzbekistan, in projects and works, including those co-financed by international financial institutions.

The Association is ready to accept members. Also, after solving organizational issues, it is necessary to initiate certification procedures for specialists of relevant professions, which will push the subjects of the sphere to join the Association. It has been and is everywhere, and we are no exception.

The construction sector is classified as hazardous industries. Are there any problems here?

The problem of occupational safety and health in construction remains one of the most urgent, as its solution affects the immediate interests of each of the more than 1.5 million workers in the industry.

The reasons for the violation of labor discipline in construction are mainly reduced to the low qualifications of workers who do not understand the reasons and consequences of deviation from the regulations. Violations by members of the administrative staff, as a rule, are associated with beliefs in the redundancy of security measures and the presence of a certain invisible "tolerance" that provides a deviation from norms and rules.

It should be noted that the causes of accidents at the construction site and harm to the health of workers are associated not only with violations of the technology of construction processes and ways to protect people, but also with possible errors at the design stage.

In general, the relationship between an enterprise and a construction worker concerning safety is regulated by law. As my experience in the construction industry shows, the main traumatic factors in the implementation of construction work are falling from a height, collapsing or falling objects on a person, injuries during the operation of equipment, machinery and mechanisms, electrical injuries and others.

Many developers, managers of construction companies always strive to save on safety, as this is associated with costs. But they forget that construction at all stages involves a large number of dangerous factors. First of all, it is working at height, working with toxic and flammable materials. Equally important among the hazard factors is the work with specialized equipment, such as cranes, loading vehicles, as well as welding machines, various power tools: drills, circulars, jackhammers and others. Therefore, compliance with safety rules on construction sites is given a separate place. Firstly, when applying for a job in a construction organization, everyone undergoes an initial briefing, a note about which the employer must put in a special journal and other documents. Before starting work on the construction site, each builder undergoes an introductory briefing, which describes the working conditions, hazards, and rules. In addition, absolutely all employees of a construction organization (from a handyman to a director) undergo periodic instruction with a mandatory knowledge check. An employee has no right to start work without successfully passing this check.

In conclusion, I would like to note that the implementation of labor protection at the construction site is the key not only to successful work, but also to the health and preservation of the lives of all employees who take part in construction.

They say that in the construction business, the proportion of so-called "off-the-shelf workers" who are not properly registered by employers still remains significant.

What consequences can this lead to?

Most often, companies shy away from signing an employment contract in order to save money. But it happens that the employee himself thinks that it is more profitable for him to work informally: he will not have to pay taxes, plus he can easily "quit" at any time. This also often happens when there are relatives among the employees or a person works for himself.

Yes, informal employment is also present in the construction sector. Why do some people choose informal employment? For obvious reasons. For the employer, the rates of deductions from the official salary of employees look extremely unprofitable. He also believes that accepting an employee "on bird rights", he will get unlimited power over him, will be able to ignore the norms of labor legislation, that he will not be responsible to the employee and the law.

The employee has other reasons, such as the possibility of avoiding various deductions from the salary. Often an employee is simply forced to go for informal employment when it is difficult to find a similar official job in the same specialty and with the same level of remuneration.

In all other respects, the interests of the employee and the employer do not just diverge, but are also grounds for conflicts.

Having legalized the employment relationship, that is, having properly formalized them, the employee receives guarantees established by law, that is, at least he will be required to pay his salary in full under the contract, fines will not be deducted from the salary (often used in informal employment), the employee will be able to receive paid leave and sick leave, on his pension deductions will be sent to the account, the working day will be regulated, and will not be determined by the employer at his discretion, etc.

If the employment is "unofficial", there are risks: not to receive a salary in case of a conflict with the boss, or the employer, or just like that, for no reason, not to get a vacation or vacation pay, not to receive a disability certificate, to lose social guarantees related to reduction, training, pregnancy, birth of a child, etc., in case of injuries and injuries on the employer may declare that it is the first time he sees you and did not allow you to work.

If the employment relationship is not officially formalized, then the employee is absolutely not protected from dismissal at any time. If there is an employment contract, it is quite problematic for an employer to dismiss an employee without his consent.

Galina Sobirovna, now a highly qualified personnel worker is "worth its weight in gold". What advice would you give to an HR specialist to become in demand? If possible, on your example…

Briefly about my career path ... Having received a financial education, I realized that it was more interesting for me to work with people, I wanted to realize my communicative inclinations and skills. In this regard, she was trained at the Tyumen Institute for Advanced Training of managers and Specialists in the courses "Improving work with the personnel of construction organizations" and received the specialty of the head / lead manager of the personnel department. Then she repeatedly participated in seminars, various HR trainings, applying the acquired knowledge in practice. Having gained practical experience, a little later she herself conducted training sessions and seminars, gave lectures. Today I have been working in the HR field for more than 25 years, or HR, as it is customary to say now, and believe me, I get great satisfaction from the work I have been doing all these years!

What advice? It's pretty simple. You need to constantly improve your skills and knowledge, and at the same time apply them in practice. Consult, consult with experienced HR specialists, do not hesitate to ask, even if the questions seem simple to you, but to which you do not know the answers. Delve into every aspect of HR records management. Every employee of the personnel sphere should be partially and competent lawyer, know the nuances and subtleties of labor legislation. And believe me, this invaluable experience gained in the process of acquiring new knowledge and using it in practice will help you become a really in-demand specialist.

By the way, speaking of courses and trainings… There are not so many of them now, especially high-quality and really useful ones. By the way, I was invited to conduct trainings in several organizations, but the target audience that I am most in demand is HR specialists in construction and related areas, which is why I agreed to participate in courses and trainings planned for the Association of Consulting Engineers of Uzbekistan.

And at the end of our conversation, what would you suggest focusing on from the point of view of staffing the transformation processes of the construction and design spheres in the republic?

The main task is to attract young people to the construction sector, increase the prestige of the construction profession. In this direction, the efforts of the state, the construction sector, and educational institutions of the architectural and construction direction should be combined. Holding specialized exhibitions, trade fairs, competitions, professional orientation and consulting, development and financial support of field construction teams, based on the results of work in which, for example, a personal certificate would be issued, will make the career prospects that can be achieved by students open and understandable. This is the only way we will be able to form a reliable personnel reserve for the coming years.

Another solution to the personnel problem can be targeted training of specialists in the direction of regions, enterprises and organizations or within the framework of state programs. Practice shows that in this case, the level of training of specialists, responsibility and motivation of trainees for the quality of education received increases. The target direction allows the future graduate not to think much about employment after graduation, because the future place of work has already been initially determined. The target is obliged to find a job in the organization that sent him to study and paid for training, to work there for a certain time. For this reason, the employer (customer), as an interested person, oversees the educational process, accepts students for practice, internships; recommends the implementation of real projects during their studies. The targeting of personnel training by educational institutions for organizations that are employers in the future should become a widespread norm.

Increasing the motivation of design and construction organizations themselves in personnel training is another reserve. In cases when construction organizations assume the functions of partners of an educational institution, participate in the educational process and, having concluded contracts with universities and colleges, regularly accept students for practice (internship), appoint experienced specialists as managers of industrial training, tax breaks can be provided here. Such a measure will contribute to improving the quality of personnel training.

I will also say that modern construction is a dynamic process that requires updating the knowledge of specialists every three to five years. Every builder, architect should remember that the only way to be in demand in any socio-economic conditions is to follow the principle of "education for life". Additional professional education is the engine of a career. It allows you to gain new knowledge, skills and approaches to solving professional tasks.

It is also necessary to study and use advanced domestic and foreign experience in the training of highly qualified personnel, advanced training and professional retraining of managers and specialists of organizations in the design and construction fields.

Galina Sobirovna, thank you so much for the informative interview.

The interview was conducted by a PR specialist

Associations of Consulting Engineers of Uzbekistan

Alimova G.F.

The interview was prepared by the Association of Consulting Engineers of Uzbekistan within the framework of the ENGINE project, co-funded by the European Union.

The content of this publication does not reflect the official opinion of the European Union. The responsibility for the information and opinions expressed in the article lies entirely with its author (UZACE).